Considering the Prisoner’s Dilemma in this chapter, provide your own insight on how sites such as eBay “work” for most participants of this popular online auction site. Do they really work? Or is there too much risk?
Most people selling on eBay are people who are trying to get rid of old junk and just make a dollar. Those people buying on eBay are generally trying to get something cheap. This creates two goals. Selling something cheap does not make as much money and making more money requires that people pay a higher price. Here is a clear dilemma. In order for auction sites to work both parties must find an equal value for which they are willing to buy and sell their product for.
Each party must also trust the other. As in the prisoner's dilemma, one must trust the other to get the best outcome for each. However the buyer could decide that the minimum bid is too high, the seller gets nothing and must hold onto the item and the buyer looses nothing or the seller drops the price and makes less money and the buyer get exactly what they wanted. On the other hand the buyer could be tricked into spending more for a product. The seller could have multiple screen names and up-bid their own product. They seller could also sell something that is less quality than what they may lead to believe.
Both of the previous situations can be avoided with trust. If there is a way to ensure trust the idea of eBay could be foolproof, as would the idea of stealing and crashing a car like in Shirky's chapter. Trust is a major part of buying and selling online. The site eBay attempts to improve trust between patrons of the site by providing areas that users can leave feedback for each other. EBay then compiles the feedback for other users to see. This allows buyers to rate the trustworthiness of a seller. This is enough for most users. They will select a seller with a higher satisfaction rating than one with a low rating.
Other users do not even look at this feedback and trust in the goodness of people or simply trust in the reputation of the site. If a large percent of customers lied cheated and stole to make more money less and less people would use the site to make purchases, but the site survives. The fact that eBay and other auction and bidding sites exists and continue to make money show that even with the framework of a prisoner's dilemma in place the sites still work. People are obviously still interested in using the tools provided and trust the other users as they hope they are trusted.
There are obvious risks involved with making purchases on eBay. There may even be too mush risk for those skeptical people. But over all the use of the auction site is too high for someone to believe that there is too much risk. EBay has built up a solid reputation and seems to have helped people stay within the boundaries of the win-win (or rather less loss-less loss) choice in the prisoners dilemma.
Showing posts with label shirky. Show all posts
Showing posts with label shirky. Show all posts
Tuesday, November 16, 2010
FOAF
What professional benefits do you see by investing some time in a FOAF-style network?
Many time professional services and businesses rely on connections, especailly small business. Freind of a Friend or FOAF style networking is all about connections. If someone is a friend of mine and they then meet a different friend of mine there is now a connection between them, me. This is what happens with a friend of a fiend network only I do not need to be involved any sort of way. The network makes all the connections for us. In Clay Shirky's book, he speaks about a social network tool called dodgeball. This tool not only allows you to find connections online but it allows people to physically find someone who is also updating their location. It uses the connection between friends and the information they upload to various social network sites to connect people with each other.
A basic example is the friend wheel on facebook. Here is my friend wheel, it shows how each of my firends connects to other friends that are also on facebook. This is not as complicated as the dodgeball scenario but still shows how many connections can be made throough just one small group of friends.
For a professional organization these connections are important. Any company that I am a part of, now has acess to all of my firneds. From my friends they can get to each of their friend wheels and this can obviously be a huge increase in customers. The expansion is also kept from being random. There is a certain order in which companies can recognize possible customers.
Using FOAF the companies can see the interests of thie current employees and customers and then look and find friends of those people with similar interests. FOAF is a tool that can is complex enough to be benificial to businesses. It is important to keep in mind however that it is just a tool. These networks only go part way. The company would have to put in work to connect the dots and work to gain the customers. It connects people through aspects about their lives but does not physically bring people together.
Small business are always in need of a larger customer base. They could use FOAF to expand. Instead of simply casting a broad net hoping to pull in at least a few customers they can target certian types of people throught this type of network. As small networks are connected through FOAF a larger network is formed. As the network grows so does the businees and so does their business's connections. With the addition of every new customer a new network can be reached. These networks will intermingle and the users of the companies service or product will become a network of their own.
Many time professional services and businesses rely on connections, especailly small business. Freind of a Friend or FOAF style networking is all about connections. If someone is a friend of mine and they then meet a different friend of mine there is now a connection between them, me. This is what happens with a friend of a fiend network only I do not need to be involved any sort of way. The network makes all the connections for us. In Clay Shirky's book, he speaks about a social network tool called dodgeball. This tool not only allows you to find connections online but it allows people to physically find someone who is also updating their location. It uses the connection between friends and the information they upload to various social network sites to connect people with each other.
A basic example is the friend wheel on facebook. Here is my friend wheel, it shows how each of my firends connects to other friends that are also on facebook. This is not as complicated as the dodgeball scenario but still shows how many connections can be made throough just one small group of friends.

Using FOAF the companies can see the interests of thie current employees and customers and then look and find friends of those people with similar interests. FOAF is a tool that can is complex enough to be benificial to businesses. It is important to keep in mind however that it is just a tool. These networks only go part way. The company would have to put in work to connect the dots and work to gain the customers. It connects people through aspects about their lives but does not physically bring people together.
Small business are always in need of a larger customer base. They could use FOAF to expand. Instead of simply casting a broad net hoping to pull in at least a few customers they can target certian types of people throught this type of network. As small networks are connected through FOAF a larger network is formed. As the network grows so does the businees and so does their business's connections. With the addition of every new customer a new network can be reached. These networks will intermingle and the users of the companies service or product will become a network of their own.
Labels:
company,
connection,
customer,
FOAF,
friend wheel,
network,
shirky,
social network tool
Thursday, November 11, 2010
Revolutionary E-mail?
Based on the quote from this chapter, “revolution doesn’t happen when society adopts new technologies--it happens when society adopts new behaviors,” do you agree or disagree? Cite examples to support your position.
Just as we have talked about before things become invisible over time. When something becomes invisible it no longer stands out and is integrated into many aspects of everyone's daily life, much like the Internet is today, or telephone. We may not remember a time, but at one point both of these ideas were revolutionary. They became truly revolutionary when people began to have other aspects of life revolve around the new technologies, not just when they started being used. I believe Clay Shirky is correct. Society truly becomes revolutionized when people's behavior is changed to fit a new technology.
Using the Internet to send e-mail, in chapter six of Shirky’s book shows a change in Societies behavior, not just an adoption of a new technology. Many to many communication is vital in today's society. E-mail is one tool that makes this possible. When society began adopting this new idea and using the Internet's capabilities to interact e-mail was not yet revolutionary. The revolution happened once there was no other logical way to send a mass letter. Revolution happens when a person's first thought, their behavior, immediately points them to the new technology. This shows a change in society’s behavior.
When society adopts the technology of e-mail it becomes one option for sending out a mass message, there were other forms of group communication. These other forms did not have the benefits that e-mail had, like quickness of delivery, inexpensive cost, and lack of need for synchronization. Once society realized the e-mail was the only reasonable way to send a mass message, it became second nature to gravitate to e-mail over any other type of communication.
E-mail in a way has become invisible in society. Once this shift to e-mail from other forms of communication happened it became revolutionary. It changed the way people thought about communication. It opened many doors of opportunity for communication. Adoption of a technology is quick, making that technology revolutionary takes more time.
Just as we have talked about before things become invisible over time. When something becomes invisible it no longer stands out and is integrated into many aspects of everyone's daily life, much like the Internet is today, or telephone. We may not remember a time, but at one point both of these ideas were revolutionary. They became truly revolutionary when people began to have other aspects of life revolve around the new technologies, not just when they started being used. I believe Clay Shirky is correct. Society truly becomes revolutionized when people's behavior is changed to fit a new technology.
Using the Internet to send e-mail, in chapter six of Shirky’s book shows a change in Societies behavior, not just an adoption of a new technology. Many to many communication is vital in today's society. E-mail is one tool that makes this possible. When society began adopting this new idea and using the Internet's capabilities to interact e-mail was not yet revolutionary. The revolution happened once there was no other logical way to send a mass letter. Revolution happens when a person's first thought, their behavior, immediately points them to the new technology. This shows a change in society’s behavior.
When society adopts the technology of e-mail it becomes one option for sending out a mass message, there were other forms of group communication. These other forms did not have the benefits that e-mail had, like quickness of delivery, inexpensive cost, and lack of need for synchronization. Once society realized the e-mail was the only reasonable way to send a mass message, it became second nature to gravitate to e-mail over any other type of communication.
E-mail in a way has become invisible in society. Once this shift to e-mail from other forms of communication happened it became revolutionary. It changed the way people thought about communication. It opened many doors of opportunity for communication. Adoption of a technology is quick, making that technology revolutionary takes more time.
Labels:
communication,
email,
internet,
revolutionary,
shirky,
society
Monday, October 25, 2010
Dukepedia
The “power law distribution” or “long tail” phenomenon, as seen in behavior online on the Wikipedia, suggests that the concept of an average user of wikipedia is meaningless. Support your answer: how do you think a local, “JMU only” version of the Wikipedia would compare to the worldwide version? Would it be very similar? Higher quality? Less quality? Why?
Wikipedia is run by a phenomenon called the power law distribution. This is defined by a huge imbalance between participation. In the wikipedia example found in chapter five of Shirky's book, out of the 129 contributing writers for the page on asphalt, six of them can take credit for about a quarter of the edits. This means that the average user of wikipedia has very few edits. A local version of Wikipedia, lets call it Dukepedia, would compare on several levels to the worldwide version. Major trends would be similar whereas the sheer volume of entries would have to be smaller.
The phenomenon of the power law distribution would still take place within a smaller community like the JMU community. If it was narrowed down to one class on campus this theory would hold less true. Just a few students would make up for most of the articles. However there would be a variety of articles, because of the variety of majors at this school. I personally may only write one article or edit a couple articles, whereas media, communications, and english majors may contribute more because it is something that they are interested in doing.
I feel that the quality of Dukepedia would be similar or comparable to that of Wikipedia. It does not take an expert in a certain field to write a quick article about a topic, especially when someone else can come later and add to it. It would take a while to catch on and really become reliable, but so did Wikipedia. Once it became known around campus people would want to join and put their two cents in. This would allow Dukepedia to get on Wikipedia's level, quality wise.
The main difference I see is the number of articles and number of contributers. The other possible problem is the type of article. Many topics are not relevant to a college atmosphere and would therefore most likely not be written. This is affected solely by the restrictions of a local community. More people in the community allows more people to edit and write more article. More writers would equal more articles. This creates a quality versus quantity argument in a way. Quality wise they would match up whereas quantity would suffer in the local version of Wikipedia.
Wikipedia is run by a phenomenon called the power law distribution. This is defined by a huge imbalance between participation. In the wikipedia example found in chapter five of Shirky's book, out of the 129 contributing writers for the page on asphalt, six of them can take credit for about a quarter of the edits. This means that the average user of wikipedia has very few edits. A local version of Wikipedia, lets call it Dukepedia, would compare on several levels to the worldwide version. Major trends would be similar whereas the sheer volume of entries would have to be smaller.
The phenomenon of the power law distribution would still take place within a smaller community like the JMU community. If it was narrowed down to one class on campus this theory would hold less true. Just a few students would make up for most of the articles. However there would be a variety of articles, because of the variety of majors at this school. I personally may only write one article or edit a couple articles, whereas media, communications, and english majors may contribute more because it is something that they are interested in doing.
I feel that the quality of Dukepedia would be similar or comparable to that of Wikipedia. It does not take an expert in a certain field to write a quick article about a topic, especially when someone else can come later and add to it. It would take a while to catch on and really become reliable, but so did Wikipedia. Once it became known around campus people would want to join and put their two cents in. This would allow Dukepedia to get on Wikipedia's level, quality wise.
The main difference I see is the number of articles and number of contributers. The other possible problem is the type of article. Many topics are not relevant to a college atmosphere and would therefore most likely not be written. This is affected solely by the restrictions of a local community. More people in the community allows more people to edit and write more article. More writers would equal more articles. This creates a quality versus quantity argument in a way. Quality wise they would match up whereas quantity would suffer in the local version of Wikipedia.
Wednesday, September 29, 2010
Media ==> Invisible
If Shirky is right, and we’re headed to a period where social media tools like YouTube, Flickr, and social networks like Facebook become “invisible,” what’s the impact on things you spend money on as consumers? Books? Movies? Music?
If social media were to become invisible people would rely less on things like books, movies, and music. There are websites that are able to take the place of all of these things currently but many people are still not used to finding and taking advantage of these resources. The social media tools have not yet crossed over into the realm of invisible, they still take the form of normal, to use Shirky's words. Eventually these tools will become second nature, and they will not be lived without. According to Shirky this is the direction that we are headed in.
If this were to happen economics would have to change. Stores would not be able to sell books, movies, and music as they once could. These media items would be, most likely, electronic. There is evidence of this transition today. Once things had to be written on paper to be transported. Later things could be typed and put on a large disc, smaller disc, and finally cds. Flash drives later were used, then attachments to emails. Now, today using google docs and other sites, typed information can simply be accessed and edited with the correct password.
This concept is also true for the three forms of media listed above. Books, movies, and music can all be downloaded online as computer files and saved to a hard drive. This is already happening. iTunes allows people to download these things without ever obtaining a physical copy. This cuts down on production costs and allows these items to purchased at a slightly less expensive rate. Eventually, with the social media sites becoming invisible the forms of media will become easier to obtain at cheaper costs and the more expensive physical copies will become obsolete or collectors items. Eventually the only obvious way to do things could become online through social networks.
Doing things through social networks will also cause one of two things to happen. Media will become extremely well put together, well sung, or well written. More people will be talking in larger forums, as the internet provides, about the media, and therefore critique more harshly than ever before. Things will need to be near perfect to become "famous." This may also take place because of sheer amount of competition. More competition means it must be better to stand out among the rest in its' genre.
If social media were to become invisible people would rely less on things like books, movies, and music. There are websites that are able to take the place of all of these things currently but many people are still not used to finding and taking advantage of these resources. The social media tools have not yet crossed over into the realm of invisible, they still take the form of normal, to use Shirky's words. Eventually these tools will become second nature, and they will not be lived without. According to Shirky this is the direction that we are headed in.
If this were to happen economics would have to change. Stores would not be able to sell books, movies, and music as they once could. These media items would be, most likely, electronic. There is evidence of this transition today. Once things had to be written on paper to be transported. Later things could be typed and put on a large disc, smaller disc, and finally cds. Flash drives later were used, then attachments to emails. Now, today using google docs and other sites, typed information can simply be accessed and edited with the correct password.
This concept is also true for the three forms of media listed above. Books, movies, and music can all be downloaded online as computer files and saved to a hard drive. This is already happening. iTunes allows people to download these things without ever obtaining a physical copy. This cuts down on production costs and allows these items to purchased at a slightly less expensive rate. Eventually, with the social media sites becoming invisible the forms of media will become easier to obtain at cheaper costs and the more expensive physical copies will become obsolete or collectors items. Eventually the only obvious way to do things could become online through social networks.
Doing things through social networks will also cause one of two things to happen. Media will become extremely well put together, well sung, or well written. More people will be talking in larger forums, as the internet provides, about the media, and therefore critique more harshly than ever before. Things will need to be near perfect to become "famous." This may also take place because of sheer amount of competition. More competition means it must be better to stand out among the rest in its' genre.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)